Right To Be A Mother
    Date :16-Nov-2026
Right To Be A Mother
current trend in law
 
 
 
 
 
 
By Adv. R. S. Agrawal : 
 
The right to make reproductive choices being recognised as a fact of personal dignity enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution definitely must operate with full force by keeping in mind the progressive interpretation of laws, in alignment with international norms and changing social dynamics, so that it ultimately ensures every couple/ an individual woman to avail the reproductive rights to its fullest by addressing the societal and systematic barriers in its way. 
 
OPENING the judgement of the case- X-1 and another v. Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare with a quote from Chinese thinker Lin Yutang, that “Of all the rights of a woman, the greatest is to be a mother,” the Bombay High Court Division Bench at Mumbai, consisting of Justice Bharati Dangre and Justice Ashish S Chavan has upheld the same by purposively interpreting the relevant provisions in the Surrogacy (Regulation Act-2021 to be read with the provisions of the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act-2021 and conferred this right on the petitioners to avail this benefit of the procedure of surrogacy under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act-2021 but the Bench has not determined the validity of the provision prescribing the age bracket for the ‘intending couple’. The Judgement was reserved earlier, on October 26,2026 and pronounced on November 4, 2026. It is this “Right to Be Mother” was claimed through this petition by ‘X-1’, a female aged 54 years and ‘X-2’, a male aged 53 years being the legally wedded spouses, both together constituting “ intending couple” within the scope of the Surrogacy Act.
 
The petitioners have filed the writ petition being aggrieved by the rejection of their application for issuance of an Eligibility Certificate under section 4 (iii) (c) of the Surrogacy Act, solely on the ground that X-1 has crossed the upper age limit prescribed under section 4(iii)(c)(I) of the Act. The petitioners have sought the said judicial review of the order and consequential relief for enforcement of their rights under Articles 14 and 21 of Constitution of India. Pleading that the petitioners have made serious and continuous efforts to conceive naturally, but the prolonged attempts remaining unsuccessful, they consulted qualified infertility specialists and underwent detailed evaluation and infertility investigations. Acting upon the expert medical advice, they underwent Assisted Reproductive Technology (‘Art’) procedures including multiple cycles of In Vitro Fertilisation (‘IVF’) at recognised Fertility Centres. It is the pleaded case of the petitioners that despite undergoing ‘ART’ procedures under expert supervision and faithfully complying with every prescribed medical protocol, the treatment did not result in a successful clinical pregnancy.
 
It is June, 26,2026 ,on consulting an IVF Specialist in Nashik a medical opinion was obtained, in that it was stated that, “Age of X-1 is 54 years and under the Surrogacy Act, the age of the woman shall not exceed 50 years and, therefore, the Eligibility and Essentiality Certificate cannot be issued to the petitioners.” It is this rejection, which was under challenge. The right to make reproductive choices being recognised as a fact of personal dignity enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution definitely must operate with full force by keeping in mind the progressive interpretation of laws, in alignment with international norms and changing social dynamics, so that it ultimately ensures every couple/ an individual woman to avail the reproductive rights to its fullest by addressing the societal and systematic barriers in its way.
 
The HC has clarified that it has not ruled upon the validity of the provision prescribing the maximum age limit and whenever such challenge is faced, all the relevant aspects including the study of impact of age in rearing up children at advanced age will receive due consideration. However, the Court has not pronounced upon the issue of the validity, as the HC is conscious of the fact that the Court in exercise of its jurisdiction shall have very limited or rather very little scope to interfere with the legislative wisdom unless or until it is established that its implementation results into arbitrariness and which can be established on well settled touchstone of testing arbitrariness. Since it should always be the endeavour of a Court to adopt a purposive interpretation and ensure that the object behind a legislation is achieved, by adopting as interpretation, which assists in attaining the object and as far as the Surrogacy Act is concerned, it is a regulatory statute regulating the practice and process of surrogacy and aimed at prohibiting potential exploitation of surrogate mothers and to protect the rights of the children born through surrogacy. The petitioners-X-1and X-2-before the Court were denied the Eligibility Certificate, as one of them has crossed the age bracket and the High Court has expressed agreement with the Amicus Curiae Jagtiani, who brought before the Court another perspective of purposively interpreting section 4(iii)(c)(I), and particularly when this is so applied to a ‘ commissioning couple’ under the ‘ART’ Act. The HC deemed it appropriate to assist the petitioners, the ‘intending couple’ before the Court, by issuing the following directions:
 
1. The HC quashed and set aside the order of July 14, 2026 passed by the Appropriate Authority respondent-5, Nashik Municipal Corporation under the Surrogacy(Regulation) Act-2021, by which the petitioners’ application for issuance of an Eligibility Certificate under section 4(iii)(c) of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act. 2021 was rejected on the ground that the petitioner No. 1 has crossed the upper age limit as set out under section 4(iii)(c)(I) of the Act, to issue an Eligibility Certificate.
2. By adopting purposive interpretation, the HC has issued writ of mandamus to the Appropriate Authority under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, Nashik Municipal Corporation to issue an Eligibility Certificate in favour of the petitioners, in the wake of reasoning indicated by the Court in its judgement and declared that the petitioners are eligible for undergoing the process of surrogacy and the factum that one of them X-1has crossed the age of 50 shall not pose an embargo in they being subjected to the procedure of surrogacy and if required, the ‘ART’ procedure.
3. The HC has also issued writ of mandamus to District Medical Board, Nashik to issue the Certificate of Medical Indication, if the petitioners otherwise satisfy the medical requirements prescribed under the Surrogacy Act and Rules. The High Court has rejected the request made by the Union of India counsel to stay the judgement, as it wanted to test the judgement before the Supreme Court.