Column

VINDICTIVE SUSPENSION QUASHED

The petitioner fundamentally seeks the relief of quashing of the order of suspension, coupled with a consequential direction commanding the respondent to permit the petitioner to continue to discharging his duties on the post of Police Station Officer, Manpur in the Indore district...

Of the license to mess up with public interest

 By Vijay Phanshikar : WHAT is the most important attribute of civic administration ? Responsiveness ! This is what is taught to students in their course on public administration -- not only in India but also all over the world. Public..

Development...Served hot!

  By Biraj Dixit : “As hot as hell!” This idiomatic simile may be part of the many myths associated with hell (as no one has returned to confirm or reject those), but it absolutely serves its purpose when describing Indian summe..

Of an extraordinarily quiet mind

POSSIBLY, ordinary mortals do not understand the “immeasurable” -- that vast, timeless nature of existence -- because they cannot keep their minds “extraordinarily quiet, still”. For, to achieve such a state, is the toughest task in life -- and most mortals find themselves particularly unsuited to achieve that goal of a completely still mind -- where even the smallest vibration does not escape notice. Of course, J. Krishnamurti often talks of the quiet mind, the still mind. In his commentaries on ..

Mixed Luck for Workman

 By Adv. R. S. Agrawal : Respondent-Company has stated to have examined the past service record of the petitioner and consequently, the management decided that the petitioner ought to have been terminated after which the petitioner remain..

Of “doing nothing”to bust stress instressful times

 THERE,ofcourse,areseveral formulae available in the market for busting stress -- including physical exercise, playing sports, reading, listening to music,talkingtofriends,cooking, gardening, knitting ...!But “doingnothing”forsometime on..

Who is responsible for this scandal? Who is backing it?

The city has been hit by another land-related scandal. Vested interests have gobbled up 15.5 acres of land (in Pardi -- East Nagpur) originally reserved for usage as crematorium in the Development Plan. And this detail surfaced in a Nagpur Municipal Corporation’s review meeting chaired by none other than Mayor Mrs. Neeta Thakre. The meeting was told that only 1.5 acres of the land now remain -- to be used as crematorium. This information was shared with the members by officials at the meeting...

Pawar-Play 2.0

The Pawar family drama has definitely moved on to the next generation. After Ajit Pawar’s desperate attempts to come out of the massive shadow of uncle Sharad Pawar finally culminated into a vertical split in the party, the story has travelled to ‘who is the most powerful Pawar in Baramati’. Though the Pawars are known for their close family relations away from politics, this time the aspirations of the new crop of leaders are likely to see the ‘friendly fire’ turning into a fierce turf war...

Of inner light in twilight

 By Vijay Phanshikar : Evening arrives when a tired afternoon says ‘goodbye’ ... ... twilight !- Self AFTERNOON’S bright glow gives way to evening’s twilight -- rather hesitant, rather indolent, rather even..

Reasoned One Conclusion

HAVING the considered opinion that it would be neither appropriate nor proper for the Court to interfere with the impugned decision in exercise of the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, particularly having regard to the well-settled parameters governing the exercise of jurisdiction in matters relating to the award of public contracts, the writ petition filed by M/s G.H. Khandelwal, on the subject, could not win favour of the Bombay High Court division Bench at Nagpur, consisting ..

Inability To File Recovery

It is the case of the petitioner, that the respondent failed to pay bonus to the employees as stipulated. Repeated representations made by the petitioner and the Workmen did not yield any response. Such conduct, according to the petitioner constituted an unfair labour practice...

No generalisation, please, about Gen Z(ee) !

 By Vijay Phanshikar : OF COURSE, accusations float around that members of Gen Z(ee) are irresponsible and superficial and indisciplined. What hurts most is the sense of generalisation in those accusation -- that every Gen Z(ee) member is irresp..

Of the overwhelming emotion for Kasturchand Park !

 By Vijay Phanshikar : THE strong emotions expressed unabashedly by countless people -- openly or privately -- in favour of a public campaign to save the historic Kasturchand Park from getting permanently spoiled due to official encroachment wer..

Ashatai, Dravid … Faith!

Asha Bhosle has left a rich legacy and a precious message for all the second fiddle to see its ephemerality that they generally take as their destiny. Apart from her extraordinary singing breadth, it will be the most powerful lesson not just for her fans but also for every human seeking one’s own silhouette in the world of massive shadows...

SC ‘NO’ TO DIFFERENTIAL RATES

The issue in the case, is not about entitlement to DR on pension. Once pension is admissible and, based on inflation, DR is admissible on it, announcing the DR at the rate lower than at what DA is provided, when both are linked to inflation and serv..

Robust Arms Policy

By Adv. R. S. Agrawal : The present writ petition has been filed challenging the order passed on November 20, 2025, by the Additional Commissioner, Mirzapur whereby the appeal filed by the petitioner against the order of November 24, 2022, pas..

Of trees waiting to be ‘dechoked’

THE Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) was expected to start ‘dechoking’ of 3000-plus trees in the city -- as per the direction of the honourable High Court (as part of the next phase of the effort). This effort, no doubt, was an urgent need of the city. To that extent, the city must welcome the direction of the honourable High Court and expect that the work on the project would be done with diligence and discipline. Of course,’The Hitavada’ has been campaigning for ‘dechoking’ of trees for the past ..

Of the metaphor of flight

 By Vijay Phanshikar :For once you have tasted flight, you will walk the earth with your eyes turned skyward, for there you have been and there you will long to return.- Leonardo da Vinci,Sculptor, scientist, painter, doctor, diplomat, philosopher..

Competence Not Only Test

The petitioner has been Primary Teacher at Government Primary School in the District Shivpuri and he was placed under suspension, alleging that he posted an objectionable video with an intent to cause disturbance in society. The video posted by the petitioner does not contain any objectionable material which could cause disturbance in society. In the video the he has merely stated about the shortage of LPG gas prevailing in the society due to Israel-Iran war. It was also urged that the act of the ..

The ‘Superpower’ Myth

 By Rahul Dixit: The last few years have brought a humbling experience for all those flexing their military muscle against assumed minnows. Not only have the weaklings put up a sterling fight against the mighty but also have become the new David..

The War Games

A LL the prayers for the end of the war are yet to be answered. Skies are still bearing the brunt of human Afollies flying high. Bombs are destroying cities, eroding life and whatever is good around it. Someone is calling for a ceasefire but the fire is still blazing. Upon the debris of human life,aflag awaits hoisting. Of the many crimes, wars are the least accused of...

Court And Banking Cases

Though one of the objects of the 1986 Act is to provide speedy and simple redressal to consumer disputes, its object is not to deal with complex and factual issues pertaining to criminal or tortuous liability in a summary manner. The complaint allegations cannot be adjudicated upon in a proceeding under the 1986 Act, as those allegations could be appropriately addressed in a regular criminal or civil proceeding. As a result, the appeal lacks merit and was, accordingly, dismissed...

Of unforgiving commitment ofhigh achievers

SPORTS are not all play -- or only playing a game. Sports involve much more. To some, sports become a lifetime of commitment beyond comfort zones. And that is a no-nonsense activity. That activity claims so much from the person who is directly engaged in playing, and also from the person or persons acting in support, that everything else has to take a back-seat. Unfortunately, the larger society does not see that behind-the-scene activity. But if we take a close look at that activity, we will realise ..

Who gobbled up our lakes ? Who is the real sinner ?

 By Vijay Phanshikar : Once again, we must ask the question to ourselves : Who gobbled up those 6-7 beautiful, wonderful lakes in Nagpur ? Whose neck should be caught in the wringer for this sin ? Who is the real culprit, the real sinner ? For,..

Mumbai Varsity Given Relief

PARTLY setting aside and modifying the impugned judgement passed by the Industrial Court, Mumbai, on November 28, 2023, Justice Sandeep V. Marne, at the Bombay High Court has allowed in part the writ petition filed by the University of Mumbai on March 13, 2026 with direction to the petitioners to pay to the respondent-employees difference of wages between the one actually paid and the one payable, considering the entry pay in the minimum of the pay scale applicable to the posts held by them plus dearness ..

When silence works ...

Taking sides at the peak of a conflict is not India’s style of diplomacy. It responds with a long-term view and distinct assessment, prioritising its own interests. Analysts are keenly watching this strategic silence with a special focus. New Delhi has still kept its cards close to the chest, appealing for peace and dialogue but choosing neutrality. This silence is not a weakness but a position with multiple benefits. Amid the fire and fury, India is making the most sophisticated diplomatic moves ..

When bud blooms into flower !

WHEN does a bud become a flower ?! Very few can claim to have captured that precise moment. Of course, pre-set cameras have captured those precious moments. For the ordinary mortals, though, that moment has often remained elusive. Children the world over often spend nights awake and alert to actually see a bud bloom into a flower -- a vain wait, though. No matter how alert you are and how focused in your watch of the bud in those precious moments before its petals open, you miss the actual loosening ..

Women’s Day referral:Two memoirs, same message

 By Vijay Phanshikar : IN HER well-scripted memoir “My Life in Full: Work, Family and Our Future” (2021 - Portfolio/ Penguin), Indra Nooyi, the iconic Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of PepsiCo, off and on touches upon issues that wome..

Beneficiaries of “System”

IN THE Order passed on February 18, 2026, in the case-VBR Menon v. The Chief Controller of Explosives, Petroleum and Explosives Safety Organisation (PESO), Nagpur and 8 others, a Madras High Court Division Bench consisting of the Chief Justice Manindra Mohan Shrivastava and Justice G Arul Murugan, has pointed out that “the material which is floating at the surface requires much deeper and fair investigation by examining the role of beneficiaries for whose benefit the entire system is operating”. The ..

‘Civil’isation: Work in progress

SINGING out loudly, trying to keep in sync with the radio singer, I turned right from Lokmat Chowk. Just as I turned, the traffic light turned yellow. I increased the speed, and then braked hard. Right in front was a yellow board that must have come up during night, stating in bold letter, ‘DIVERSION’. By this time, traffic from the opposite side had started flowing, vehicles behind me formed a queue and soon the situation turned chaotic. I was struggling to maneuver my way into a constant flow of ..

Naming All Family Members

In the judgement of the case- Vaibhav Gopaldas Mundada (31) & 4 others v. State of Maharashtra & another, pronounced on February 20, 2026, Justice Pravin S. Patil at the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court has voiced his “opinion”, that after considering overall factual and legal position of this case, as per the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the cases of Preeti Gupta, Achin Gupta and Dara Lakshmi, it is clear that it is the case, where the Non-Applicant-2, Neha Vaibhav Mundada (30), on ..

Inter-Faith Marriage

This case reveals a shocking state of affairs. There is no dispute that the petitioner is a major and was, at all relevant times a major. Hence the petitioner-wife is free to marry anyone she likes or to live with anyone she likes. There is no bar to an inter-caste marriage under the Hindu Marriage Act or any other law. Hence, we cannot see what offence has been committed by the petitioner, her husband or her husband’s relatives...

Of the reason whyfamily dialoguemay be missing

 By Vijay Phanshikar : “We switch off television at mealtime -- for decades now. No TV, no mobiles. Each mobile set is consciously kept away as all of us sit down for both meals. We are fortunate that even in morning, we are able to have..

The privileged 0.01%

O NE chore that is lined up for each Sunday, my off day, is stocking up the weekly grocery, vegetables and fruits. Soa trip to the grocery store or a supermarket in the vicinity is mandatory. I love walking through the aisles, browsing through the various shelves. Every week new products are added, and this gives me an opportunity to pass time, which I have in surplus. Reading the labels, scanning their QR codes is pure fun. It was during one such trip to the supermarket when I was scanning around ..

‘No one’s illegal on a stolen land’

SINGER Billie Eillish may have won Grammy’s ‘Song of the Year’ for Wildflower, but this powerful sentence uttered as part of her acceptance was no less a ‘song.’ It held the mirror high. It’s not likely that people - powerful, self-obsessed - may see the mirror yet. But once the mirror of truth is placed, one cannot ignore it for too long. It is funny how easily the uninterrupted flow of history is often diverted to channel one’s own narrative. Focus on one little detail, cry hoarse about it and all ..

Of music’s caress and connect

“Music was my refuge. I could crawl into the spaces between notes and curl my back to loneliness. In my rented room (cooking privileges down the hall), I would play a record, then put my arms around the shoulders of the song. As we danced, glued together, I would nuzzle into its neck, kissing the skin, and rubbing its cheek with my own. ...” - Maya Angelou (1928-2014),..

Medical Negligence

It must be remembered that sometimes despite their best efforts, the treatment by doctor fails and sometimes despite efforts of a surgeon, patient dies. However, that does not mean that the doctor/surgeon must be held to be guilty of ‘medical negligence’, unless there is some strong evidence to suggest that he has not taken due care and caution while treating the patients...

Of a lazy, sleepy, sloppy civic administration !

The rules -- Solid Waste Management (SWM) Rules -- are clear: There must be a buffer zone around every garbage dumping yard. However, at the Bhandewadi Dump-Yard on the eastern fringe of Nagpur, this part of the rule cannot just be implemented. For, as even a street urchin in the city knows, years ago, the fringes of Bhandewadi yard were encroached upon by people who built their ‘pukka’ houses -- no matter the stench and the filth of the mountains of garbage in the yard just outside their compound ..

Hold The Bubbly

The Indo-US trade deal is yet to be inked formally. Some pain-points still need tender handling. The deal was unilaterally announced by Trump through social media. A joint note is yet to come out about the modalities of the agreement. India has acknowledged the US initiative to take ahead the negotiations. PM Narendra Modi has also thanked Trump on behalf of Indians for lowering the tariffs. However, there is still no clear word about finalisation of a trade deal. The purposeful silence over the words ..

Committing Case to Sessions

As per section 325 of the Code, if the Magistrate is of the opinion that after hearing the evidence for the prosecution and the accused that accused found guilty and punishment is to be imposed for which the Magistrate is not empowered, he is required to record the opinion and submit the proceedings, and forward the accused to the CJM to whom he is subordinate...

Of continuedromance with books

A visit to the book store to mark the beginning of the year proved to be a great time. Thanks to professional commitments claiming a lot of time, such a rendezvous had become a rarefied activity -- and one longed to take a deep and endearing look at book shelves seeking new titles of authors well known and not so well known. Of course, buying new books is always a pleasure, no matter the cost, but even looking at the books and books and books and soaking in the faint fragrance of fresh books has its ..

Cash Is King....Or So I thought

T HE other day, a group of transgender people arrived at our home, clapping in perfect rhythm and announcing - before we could even process the news - that we had officially graduated to grandparenthood. How they knew remains one of life’s great mysteries, because the baby was born in Chicago, not Nagpur. But clearly, information today travels faster than light, visas and common sense. They demanded money. Not sweets. Money. For the blessings that they were showering virtually on the tiny tot, nestled ..

Of a new face of the emerging city

By Vijay Phanshikar : Those joints are found all over the city -- posh, modern, jazzy, swanky, fashionable, and often crowded by good-looking, fashionable (mostly) young people. This is a new development -- of the last few years. And it repre..

Consensual Relationship

The allegation of false promise of marriage is also not borne out from the record. There is no material to indicate that any promise of marriage was made by the petitioner at the inception of the relationship with a dishonest or mala fide intention. The WhatsApp conversations do not disclose any assurance of marriage, nor does the complaint allege that consent, if any, was obtained on the basis of such promise prior to the alleged incident...

We cannot afford to miss taking note of NOTA vote

SO, AFTER a long time, the city of Nagpur has an elected body of corporators. It will now have a Mayor and a Deputy Mayor and a Standing Committee Chairman (with financial powers). So, the people will have their ‘own’ representatives to take care of civic matters. All this is welcome. Even as the city was still in celebratory mood, the loosefooter went around meeting people randomly to asses the actual mood...

When Nagpur confronts itself

the city of Nagpur confronts itself today as it goes to municipal polls. After a long gap -- whose explanation nobody ever had -- the people will elect their ward representatives once again. The second capital of Maharashtra, thus, will have a ‘complete’ municipal corporation -- free from the bureaucratic grip with no one to listen to the troubles, trials and tribulations of the common people. From tomorrow (January 16, 2026) onwards, the city will have ward members who will be expected to address ..

‘...Yeh saal achchha hai!!!’

  By Biraj Dixit :   “Dekhiye paate hai ushshaq buton se kya faiz Ek barahman ne kaha hai ke ye saal achchha hai...” Imagine, the great Asadullah Khan Ghalib, a master of the art of weaving rebellions into poetry, so easily submitti..

Of the promise of the sunbeam

A USUAL scene, this ! As the twilight of the dawn yields to the crimson morn, a pencil of sunlight sneaks through the slight slit in the curtains ... and draws a broadening line on the floor. The room assumes an azure glow that lilts you out of the last minutes of overnight sleep. That little play of sunbeam on the floor wakes you up fully. You smile, stretch your arms and give out an imperceptible yawn. ‘Good morning’, you say to yourself -- the day has begun ! And it has begun with a sense of promise ..

Scope Of Revisional Order

In view of adverse report furnished by the Committee, the shop-owner submitted his explanation disputing the findings of the inquiry Committee. After giving hearing to the shop-owner, the DSO passed order on January 20, 2021 holding that R 5 is guilty of breach of 18(2) of the Maharashtra Scheduled Commodities (Regulation of Distribution) Order, 1975 and, therefore, was liable for action, as contemplated under Clause 3(4) of the said Order...

We must thank ‘them’, too !

The police claim that the city of Nagpur saw lesser numbers of fatal road accidents in the year 2025 needs to be welcomed. When a city bursting at the seams reports lesser numbers of fatal accidents in a year, it is obviously a good news. For, it gives a good feeling to the people that they are plying on safer roads. As Dr. Ravinder Singal, the indomitable Commissioner of Police, made a proud announcement of the reduced numbers of fatal accidents on city roads, the people realised the good work the ..