THE one question that is bothering political
observers is whether the Congress party has found
a new formula to counter the immense popularity of Prime Minister Mr. Narendra Modi and the
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). For, so stunning has
the BJP’s bad performance in Karnataka legislative elections
been that pundits who claim to understand the electoral
behaviour of people wonder if the Congress has evolved a
new formula -- which it would use in the Lok Sabha elections, too, about one year later.
Such a formula may or may not be there, but political analysts have busied themselves in dissecting the reasons of
the BJP’s dismal performance. The most obvious reasons
that occur to them belong to the internal issues that the BJP
could not handle correctly.
Those issues had led to top-level defections from the party just a couple of weeks ahead
of election date. Persons such as former Chief Minister Mr.
Jagdish Shettar left the BJP and joined the Congress party,
thus offering a direct benefit of their move at the last minute
to the Congress party.
Besides this, the BJP also did not have a strong chief ministerial face in Mr. Basavaraj Bommai, even though he was
Chief Minister for some time. Even though the BJP did not
admit it ever, Mr. Bommai was seen to be a weak leader
against the very aggressive Congress party that employed
all sorts of political tricks to conduct its election campaign.
One of the most effective ploy the Congress party used was
to get Prime Minister Mr. Narendra Modi engaged by heaping all sorts of abuses on him. The BJP did respond to that
dirty campaign as aggressively as possible, but somehow
could not acquire the required sting in it.
It is possible that the Congress party would utilise the
Karnataka experience in the campaign for elections in other States such as Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh and
Rajasthan and try to corner the BJP and claim success.
The
BJP will have to come out with an effective response to an
upbeat Congress for the ensuing State elections and the
subsequent Lok Sabha elections.
Of course, the BJP must have analysed its performance
by now and must have started chalking out its strategy for
the coming electoral contests. In Rajasthan, the popular
mood appears to be tilted against Chief Minister Mr. Ashok
Gehlot, while in Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Mr. Shivraj
Singh Chouhan is facing similar difficulties. In Chhattisgarh,
however, Chief Minister Mr. Bhupesh Baghel appears to be
doing well for his Government. No matter these details, it
is obvious that the electoral outcome in these States would
be difficult to predict.
In all these States, the fight would be straight between the
BJP and the Congress -- in the same manner like in Karnataka.
The BJP will have to adopt newer and smarter election campaign strategies to counter the Congress party’s aggression.
The BJP, of course, has a well-oiled party organisation that
would stand it in good stead.
Its booth-level and page-level handling of the voters has acquired a legendary status in
the whole country. Factually, those plus points were with
the BJP even in Karnataka, but the party could not convert
those to its advantage.
Has the Congress party stumbled upon a smart formula
in Karnataka to counter the BJP? -- is the question then.
Those who have understood the Congress party’s internal
processes claim that there is no such magic formula. What
worked in Congress party’s favour was the internal dissensions within the BJP. Otherwise, there appears to be no special formula with the Congress party to defeat the BJP again
and again, no matter the Karnataka outcome.